Mar - Apr 2004

CPA Leadership Report
  A free bi-monthly newsletter for the accounting profession
 

CPA Leadership Report  is made possible by the generous support of the sponsoring companies. 

Promoting Continuous Improvement in CPA Firm Leadership.



Is it More Effective to Hire a Marketing Resource

or Outsource to a Specialists?

by Bob Lewis
Visionary Marketing

The first step is to measure your firm’s size. A hundred person firm needs a marketing director. No exceptions.  They may need to outsource projects to supplement efforts, but a firm this size needs a dedicated managerial resource. Firms with 50 to 100 employees should have at least a marketing coordinator to help with mailings, database management, and communications.  Firms with fewer than 50 employees probably do not need a marketing director, could use a coordinator, but often have no marketing resource.  Firms with fewer than 25 employees should outsource marketing activities.  Except in rare circumstances, they will not find a cost-effective qualified business development resource.

What is your firm doing? Are you communicating with targeted audiences or occasionally sending messages to the same group? Does the firm have direction? Are you too busy to coordinate marketing activities or do not need assistance because of a strong referral network? Most firms rely on referrals to grow, but developing and maintaining a referral network should be a planned strategy. Over time, lack of formal marketing takes its toll. Partners with established referral networks retire or leave, referral partners move on, and networks slowly contract.  All firms need to conduct active marketing efforts to maintain their practice and develop successors.

Why is marketing difficult for many firms? Perception and entrepreneurial thinking are two reasons. Many firms perceive marketing as sales. Selling is something many CPAs do not like to do and think that it is for sales reps, not professionals. This perception can cause firms to avoid sales or marketing activities, or worse, compromise and hire a sales-oriented person with no marketing savvy. Entrepreneurial thinking is the other blocker. Partners often set the direction by telling the sales or marketing person what to do. Often, partners find it difficult to accept direction from an employee or outside consultant. It is hard for senior management to let go and learn to manage the process, not dictate it. 

If you need marketing, do you hire an employee or outsource it? Create a list of objectives. What steps need to be done to achieve these goals? If you are unsure, how will an employee take the leadership role unless they have significant experience marketing for CPA firms? Hiring a marketing resource new to the CPA profession is a poor beginning to a business development effort. Look at your existing efforts.  What is being accomplished? If you have an in-house person, and it is not working, perhaps the problem is direction.  Lack of success does not mean it is the person’s fault. It could be a planning issue. Whether you hire an employee or outsource, a plan is vital.

What is Outsourcing?  Instead of hiring an employee, you hire a marketing company that becomes your marketing department. The marketing firm’s location is irrelevant. A marketing company with CPA firm experience will cut through years of learning curves. What works for a firm in Cleveland can be applied in Boston, Miami or San Francisco. Good ideas are good regardless of the geographic location of the firm. Only the targets and messages may change.

How Does Outsourcing Work.  Ninety-five percent of marketing is done via phone, direct mail, or e-mail.  If you think you need a sales person to attend chamber luncheons, rethink your strategy. A CPA firm sale is relationship driven. The prospect buys the professional, not the salesperson. The goal of CPA marketing should be to stimulate interest to the point where a prospect is interested in talking to the firm. The prospect wants to bond with a partner or manager, not the marketing person. Physical presence of the marketing person is not needed. Instead, hire a resource that knows how to conduct e-mail marketing, Internet research, and can write a good letter.

 Consider these factors:

1. Costs. An employee ranges from $35,000 to $80,000 a year including benefits, employer-related taxes, computers, office space, and other costs. A part-time solution will cost at least $20,000 to $30,000. Any less means you have an inexperienced candidate.  An outsourced firm can be retained at a budget set with costs dependent on the goals and how quickly you want them done. Outsourcing costs more per hour but less than a dedicated employee. To get a cost-effective solution, don’t look at the hourly costs. Look at the value potential of bringing in someone with marketing skills, sales experience, and ideas from other CPA firms.

2. Depth of Skills. Marketing is going electronic. Web sites, e-mail, database management, literature and direct mail design are critical skills. Can one employee have knowledge in all of these areas?  Hire a resource with the ability to expand the use of technology in marketing.

3. Comfort Zones. Carefully monitor activities. Many marketing people get too involved in working the mechanics of what is already in place, i.e., mailing newsletters or sending out tax organizers instead of developing a steady stream of new ideas. A good in-house marketing person does not do billing or scheduling and then marketing.

4. Set Expectations. Clearly identify goals and ask for a plan to achieve them. If there is disagreement with direction and expected effort, you need to know that before hiring someone. A bad start leaves a lasting impression.  The firm will retract to old ways and when attempting marketing again it will be met with the “we tried that once and it didn’t work” phrase.

The most effective method is a solution that fits your budget and produces progress.  Determine a realistic goal before committing to hiring or outsourcing. If you are unsure, read a few articles and talk to the columnists to gather ideas. This should provide insight in evaluating an employee or marketing company.

Bob Lewis is the founder of Visionary Marketing, a firm that helps CPA firms develop marketing strategies to target new clients, increase existing client revenues, and build referral partner networks. Visionary works with marketing directors, or becomes the marketing director for small to mid-size firms. Mr. Lewis can be reached at (800) 995-9186, at www.ThinkVisionary.com,  or  click here to send Bob an e-mail.

 

 

 Home  ♦  About the Firm  ♦  Consulting Services    CPA Leadership Report  ♦  Articles  ♦  CPA Event Calendar  ♦  Contact Us  ♦  Tools and Products   Service Providers

© Copyright 2003 Shiffrin Management Group, Inc. publishers of the bi-monthly newsletter CPA Leadership Report.